Examining The Impact of Water-Games-Educational Interventions on The Writing Abilities of Students With Dysgraphia In The First Section of Primary Education

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Professor, Department of Psychology, Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences, Bu Ali Sina University, Hameedan, Iran.

2 Psychology, Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences, Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamadan, Iran. ORCID COD: 0009-0006-5932-5602

3 Associate Professor, Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences, Bu-Ali Sina, University, Hamadan, Iran.

4 Assistant Professor, Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences, Bu-Ali Sina, University, Hamadan, Iran.

Abstract

By transforming writing activities into engaging and captivating ones, we can enhance the quality of students’ writing (Maleki, Naderi, Saif Naraghi, et al 2019). Water and a few inexpensive tools can provide a rich sensory and learning experience (Gross, 2012). This study investigates the effectiveness of water-based games on the performance of First Section Primary Education male students with dysgraphia, based on a Structured educational intervention. Students who struggle with writing often experience a decline in self-esteem, which, if left unaddressed, can have long-term negative effects on their academic performance and even lead to dropping out. These consequences can have harmful impacts on the individual, their family, and society as a whole (Seif Naraghi & Naderi, 2018). Writing requires mental, perceptual, and motor skills (Akyol & Kodan, 2016). Such disorders are characterized by age-related deficiencies in the quality or speed of achieving legible handwriting (Gargot, Asselborn, Zammouri, et al, 2021). The main factors contributing to poor writing and spelling problems include a lack of attention and accuracy, underdeveloped motor skills, difficulty perceiving letters and words, weaknesses in visual and auditory memory, challenges in transferring information between sensory channels, and the abstract nature of written content (Seif Naraghi & Naderi, 2018).
Water play is a fundamental aspect of early childhood education that promotes sensory and spatial awareness and physical competence (Cline & Smith, 2016) Homemade water toys can be as enjoyable as store-bought ones (Gross, 2012). It can involve different resources such as sand, ice, soap, or paint, allowing children to explore textures and temperatures and learn about the properties of water. Adding elements such as waves or moving toys enhances the senses of hearing and sight (Barber, 2006; Fanaei Nemat Sara, 2023). Water play can also support cognitive development and academic growth in various subjects (Gross, 2012).
 Gross (1946), suggests that water activities can be easily implemented in familiar environments such as home or school, where instructors can control the conditions and design the activities more precisely. In this study, we use a systematic protocol to integrate various methods and techniques of learning and teaching with water-based educational games, which can be applied in different water spaces such as tubs, glasses, water containers, and water trays. The benefits of playing with water are presented in Table 1.
Specifically, we attempt to answer two basic questions. First, does play water have a significant effect on the writing abilities of boys with dysgraphia or not? Second, does the water game affect certain aspects of writing performance? 
This study used a pre-test and post-test approach with a control group to examine the effects of a water-based game intervention on first-grade male students with special learning disabilities. We selected a sample of 30 dysgraphic students from the target population and randomly divided them into an experimental group and a control group, each consisting of 15 students. The experimental group participated in 15 sessions of the water-based game intervention (Including 5 targeted games), with three sessions per week.
By ensuring that parents were well-informed and involved in the process, we obtained their consent for the study. The inclusion and exclusion criteria were carefully established to ensure that the participants met the research requirements. This approach allowed us to gather reliable data and maintain the integrity of the study.
In this study, we used SPSS 27 software to analyze the data and various statistical techniques, including descriptive and inferential statistics. Overall, with a comprehensive analysis of the data, the absence of outliers, and confirmation of normality, the reliability of the findings increased.
We used the WICS-1V test to evaluate the standard of intelligence of students in the sample group. The dysgraphia diagnostic test was created by Yaghoobi, Afzali, and Palangi in 2017 to identify dysgraphia in students with learning difficulties. It was standardized on 332 students in grades 1–3 in the Hamadan province. The test showed a high level of reliability, with a Cronbach’s alpha of 92%. It includes components such as fine motor skills, auditory memory, auditory fluency, visual memory, visual fluency, and language comprehension. The test demonstrates construct validity and can be used for students with poor writing skills (Yaghoobi, Afzali & Palangi, 2017). In our study, the test mentioned earlier was used as a pre-test and post-test.
To examine the first research question, univariate covariance analysis was used, the results of which are presented in Table 3. The results in Table 3 show that the effect of the pre-test was significant, and its selection as a covariate variable was effective. The effect of the group was also significant (p<0.01, F = 67/14), which means that playing with water had a significant effect on the writing performance of male students with dysgraphia in the first elementary course, and according to the Eta square, this effect was 71%.
To investigate the second research question, multivariate covariance analysis was used, the results of which are presented in Table 4. To check the significance of the difference in the average of the components of dysgraphia, Wilks’s lambda multivariate statistic was investigated. The results of this test are shown in Table 5. Playing with water significantly affects fine motor skills, listening memory, visual memory, and visual discrimination in dyslexic male students, as shown by covariance analysis. However, it did not significantly affect auditory discrimination or receptive language.
Water play gives children unique opportunities to learn various skills (Fanaei Nemat Sara Z., 2023; Gross, 1946). This approach aligns with teaching methods used for children, such as multiple sensory and perceptual-motor methods (Siadatian, Abedi, Sadeghian, et al, 2015). As it improves hand-eye coordination and other perceptual-motor skills such as body perception, balance, orientation, spatial orientation, and eye tracking (Gross, 1946). Water play also integrates sensory dimensions, such as visual, auditory, movement, touch, and balance, which can strengthen reading, dictation, and writing skills. Overall, engaging in water play has a noteworthy and beneficial influence on writing performance and its various components. Therefore, it is recommended to incorporate this approach into educational and therapeutic settings.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Akyol H., & Kodan H. (2016). “Okuma guclugunun giderilmesine yoönelik bir uygulama: Akici okuma stratejilerinin kullanimi”. Ondokuz Mayis University Journal of Education, 35(2): 7-21.
Alaniz M. L., Rosenberg S.S., Beard N. R., & Rosario E. R. (2017). “The Effectiveness of Aquatic Group Therapy for Improving Water Safety and Social Interactions in Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Pilot Program”. Autism and Developmental Disorders, 47: 4006-40017.
Azimigarosi S., Arjmandnia A., Mohseni Ezhei A., & Asgari M. (2021). “Effectiveness of Hydrotherapy on Communication Skills of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Single Case Study”. J Child Ment Health. 6 (4):35-50. [in Persian].
Baggerly J., & Parker M. (2005). “Child-centered group play therapy with African American boys at the elementary school level”. Journal of Counseling &Amp; Development83 (4):387-396.
Barber, J. (2006). “Playing with water”. The care environment. https://www.magonlinelibrary.com, by 134.102.107.192.
 Begecarslan E., Şahin F., Azenel B., Kazmaz E., & Burçin Gürbey Z. (2021). “Developing STEM skills with water games in early childhood”. International Journal of Learning and Teaching. 4, 184-203.
Brown, D. (2019). Different types of literacy conflict and how to create conflict in writing. available from WWW. masterclass.com
Cline J. E., & Smith B. A. (2016).” Water play”. Journal of STEM Arts Crafts, and Constructions, 16-22.
Dada Sh., Flores C., Bastable K., & Schlosser R.F. (2021) “The effects of augmentative and alternative communication interventions on the receptive language skills of children with developmental disabilities: A scoping review”. International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 23 (3): 247-257.
Deschamps L., Devillaine L., Gaffet C., Lambert R., Aloui S., et al. (2021). “Development of a Pre-Diagnosis Tool Based on Machine Learning Algorithms on the BHK Test to Improve the Diagnosis of Dysgraphia”. Advances in Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning. 1 (2): 114-135.
Fanaei Nemat Sara, Z. (2023). The effect of playing with water on the reading and writing performance of dyslexic and dysgraphic male students in the first grade of primary school. Master's thesis. Yaghoobi A. Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences, Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamadan, Iran. [in Persian].
Farrokh Alaee F. (2023).” Multisensory Teaching and TBR Oscillatory Activities in Foreign Language Vocabulary Retention: A Neurolinguistic Study”. US-China Education Review A. 13(4), 175-186.
Gargot T., Asselborn T., Zammouri I., Brunelle J., Johal W., Dillenbourg P., & Anzalone S.M. (2021).  “It Is Not the Robot Who Learns, It Is Me.” Training Severe Dysgraphia Using Child-Robot Interaction”. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 12: 509-526.
Gillingham, A., & Stillman, B. W. (1997). The Gillingham Manual: remedial training for students with specific disability in reading spelling and penmanship (8th ed. rev). Educators Pub. Service
Gross C. M. (2012). “Science Concepts Young Children Learn Through Water Play”. Dimensions of Early Childhood, 40(2):3-12
Hafina, A., Nur L., & Rusmana, N. (2020). “Fostering Cognitive Ability Through Game-Based Aquatic Learning in Early Childhood”. Advances in Social Science, Education, and Humanities Research, 438: 54-57.
Hamaguchi P., Bagheri N., & Ghanai, A. (2019). Astan Quds Razavi Publishing House, first edition, Mashhad. [in Persian].
Hansen L. M. (2018). Teaching Academic Concepts in a Play-Based Preschool Environment: A Case Study of Guided Play across Three Classrooms. Doctoral Dissertations.
Hashemi N., Azimzadeh, E., & Ghasemi, A. (2020). “Effect of playing in the water of Autistic children on their mothers’ stress”. Journal of Sports Psychology, 12(1), 1-11
Hashemi, S., & Abuhamzeh, A. (2020). “Disgrafia Improvement Techniques in Primary School Students at Shahid Beheshti Elementary School”. Research in humanities education, 2020. 6(19): 15-20. [in Persian].
Isnaini R., & Katoningsih, S. (2021). “Problematics of Improving Fine Motor Abilities of Children Age 5-6 Years”. ECRJ, 4: 57-64.
Javadiasayesh, S., Arjmandnia, A., & Kashanivahid, L. (2021). “The effect of hydrotherapy on stereotype behaviors in children with autism spectrum disorder”. Journal of Psychological Science. 20(102), 901-910. [in Persian].
Julia, K., Hartnett, M.S., & CCC-SLP. (2022). “Speech & Language Therapy at Nemours Children's Health”. https://kidshealth.org/en/parents/speech-therapy.html.
Langendorfer Stephen J. (2009). “Water Learning: Improving Mental, Physical, and Social Skills Through Water Activities”. International Journal of Aquatic Research and Education, 3(1), Article 9.
Maleki L., Naderi E., Saif Naraghi M., & Ali Asgari M. (2019). “Designing and Validation Supplementary Curriculum for Dysgraphia’s Students in First Level of Elementary School”. JOEC, 2019. 19 (2):17-34. [in Persian].
Mohammadi, F., Eghbali, A., Motaali, L., & Karimi, S. (2014). “The comparison between the effectiveness of two methods, Gillingham-Orton and Practice-Repetition, on the improvement of elementary students with dysgraphia”. Educational and Scholastic studies, 3(3), 99-117.
Nazari H., Timas, A., & Khadem Masjedi, H. (2021). “The effectiveness of etymology of words to reduce spelling errors due to difficulties in the alphabet of Persian language in 4th grade elementary students”. Research in Teaching, 9(2): 52-29. [in Persian].
Nur L., Hafina A., Rusmana, N., Suryana, D., & Abdul Malik, A. (2019). “Basic Motor Ability: Aquatic Learning for Early Childhood”. Journal of Physical Education, Sport, Health and Recreations, 8: 51–54.
Nur L., Hamdu, G., Mulyadiprana, A., Nuraeni, E., & Yulianto, A. (2019). “Thematic learning design development: STEM model through water play activity”. J. Phys.: Conf. 1318 012051.
Olowe P.K, Ojoko B.A., & Onuegbu I.E. (2020). “Water and Sand Play: More than Just Fun for Pre-school Children”. Research in Early Childhood Care & Education, 1: 17-27.
Phytanza, D.T. P., & Burhaein, E. (2019).  “Aquatic Activities as Play Therapy Children Autism Spectrum Disorder”. Int J Disabil Sports Health Sci. 2(2): 64-71.
Ram-Tsur, R., Nissim, M., Zion, M., Ben-Soussan, T. D., & Mevarech, Z. (2013). “Language Development: The Effect of Aquatic and On-Land Motor Interventions”. Creative Education, 4: 41-50.
Sadeghi A., Rabie, M., & Abedi, M. R. (2011). “Validation and reliability of the Wechsler intelligence scale for children-IV”. Developmental Psychology. 7: 377-386. [in Persian].
Salehi, L., Badri Gargari, R., & Aghdasi, A. (2021). “Comparison of the effectiveness of art-play therapy and mindfulness training on the creativity of male elementary school students”. Research in Teaching9(2): 325-301. [in Persian].
Seif Naraghi, M., & Naderi, E. (2020). Specific learning disabilities: stage of diagnosis and rehabilitation methods. 10 ed. Tehran: Ars Baran. [in Persian].
Sharifi, A., & Davari, R. (2012). “Prevalence of learning disabilities in first and second-grade students of the elementary school in Chaharmahal Va Bakhtiari Province”. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1(2): 63-76. [in Persian].
Sharifi, T., & Rabiei, M. (2013). “Using Wechsler Intelligence Scale-4 for Diagnosing Children with Learning Disorders (Writing and Math)”. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 2: 59-75. [in Persian].
Siadatian, S. H., Abedi, A., & Sadeghian, A. (2015). “Effect of Play Therapy on Improving Auditory Attention in Students Suffering from Dysgraphia: A Single-Subject Study”. MEJDS, 2015. 4 (4):43-54. [in Persian].
Stan A. E. (2012). “The benefits of participation in aquatic activities for people with disabilities. Medicina Sportiva”. 8: 1737–1742.
Susanto E. (2012). “Model pembelajaran akuatik siswa prasekolah”. Journal of Physical Education and Sports, 1.
Tabrizi, M., Tabrizi, N., & Tabrizi, A. (2018). Disability of dictation, Diagnosis & Treatment. 17ed. Tehran: Trans psychic. [in Persian].
Yaghoobi A., Afzali A., & Palangi, M. (2017). Construction and Standardization of a Diagnostic Test for Dysgraphia Among Students with Special Learning Difficulties in the Primary Education Stage of Hamadan Province, Academic Year 1396-1397. Educational Research Institute. [in Persian].
 Yaghoobi, A., & Palangi, M. (2021). Special Learning Disorders (Definitions, Etiology, Diagnosis, Intervention). 2nd ed. Hamadan: Bo-Ali Sina University Publishing Center. [in Persian].
Yaghoobi, A., Palangi, M., & Afzali, A. (2021). “Students with special learning difficulties in the first, second, and third grades of an elementary school in Hamadan”. Research in Teaching, 9(1): 99- 120. [in Persian].
Yosef Zadeh, M. R. (2021). “The study of conflict meaning instruction method impact on first-grade senior school students creative writing skills”. Research in Teaching9(1), 134-121. [in Persian].
Zamani Behbahani, E., Asgari, P., Heydari, A., & Marashian, F. S. (2021). “The Effect of Fernald Multisensory Education on Dyslexia, Dictation Disorder and Behavioral Adaptations of Elementary Students with Learning Disabilities in Ahvaz”. Excellence in counseling and psychotherapy, 10(37): 67-81. [in Persian].