تحلیلی از اثربخشی تدریس به شیوه سماعی در درس عروض، یک مطالعه خود مردم نگارانه

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسنده

استاد زبان و ادبیات فارسی دانشگاه کردستان، سنندج، ایران

چکیده

هدف: هدف این پژوهش بیان تحلیل و تجارب تحصیل و تدریس نویسنده از درس عروض با روش خود مردم نگاری است.
روش: این روش رویکردی کیفی و خود-مردم‌نگارانه دارد. منبع داده های پژوهش، تجارب نگارنده به عنوان یکی از استادان دانشگاه در زمان تحصیل و تدریس درس عروض است که به شیوه روایتگری تنظیم و روایت های پژوهشگر در ارتباط شیوه آموزش ابداعی درس عروض تبیین و تفسیر شده است.
یافته های پژوهش: یافته های پژوهش بیانگر این است که روش سنتی تدریس عروض، آموزش این درس را برای فراگیران دشوار و کسل کننده کرده بود. روایتگر مورد مطالعه با تجربه این مشکلات در دوران دانشجویی، روشی تازه ابداع کرد. در این روش برای حاکم کردن پذیرش آموزش سماعی لازم بود ابتدا پیش‌شرط‌هایی چون آموزش واج، هجا، تقطیع، املای عروضی و افاعیل عروضی رعایت شود؛ سپس با تکیه بر فراهم آوردن طرح درس مناسب با تکیه بر استراتژی کلان(در سطح دانشگاه ها و مراکز آموزشی)و استراتژی خرد(در سطح کلاس درس) به نیازهای آموزشی فراگیران در این زمینه پاسخ داده شود. فراهم کردن نمونه های جذاب شعری، استفاده از بحور پرکاربرد و سالم، آموزش رهاسازی ذهن، ارائه نمونه های سازگار با مصادیق فرهنگی و متناسب با روحیه و سن دانشجویان و در نهایت استفاده از راهبردهای یاددهی_ یادگیری مشارکتی این درس را به یکی از دروس جذّاب و فراگیری موفقیت آمیز سماعی اوزان و بحور عروضی تبدیل کرد.

کلیدواژه‌ها


عنوان مقاله [English]

A Description for irregular teaching of prosodic lessons: a self-ethnographic study

نویسنده [English]

  • Ahmad Parsa
چکیده [English]

Purpose: the purpose of this research is showing and analyzing of the author experiences through his own learning and teaching at prosodic lessons in the form of a self-ethnographic study.
This is done by sharing the author's experiences during his studies and teaching which has resulted in increasing the impact of learners' motivation to learn this lesson by changing their attitude towards prosodic lessons. Using participatory teaching-learning strategies and providing prerequisites for teaching this lesson has resulted in these positive learning outcomes.
Method: As a qualitative research, this study carried out via a self-ethnographic study. The data source for this research is experiences and memories of one of UoK's senior lecturer (the author) in the field of prosody and its teaching in pre-university, university and in-service training of educators, which were explained, analyzed and organized in a narrative style based on the researcher’s narrations.
Among the qualitative methods, auto-ethnography has been used in this study. This method is one of the newest research methods in the qualitative approach and helps researchers to produce knowledge using personal life experiences or "biological experience" (Fazeli, 2017).
By adopting a self-critical approach in the form of retrospective and selective, an auto-ethnographer writes about his/her experiences that are essentially rooted in a part of a culture or derived from a particular cultural identity (Pitard, 2019).
To validate the research, a researcher-made questionnaire was used, the validity of which was confirmed by several instructors who taught this lesson, and it was distributed among teachers in different cities. Eighty-five percent did not feel well about the lesson, 10 percent said they had been forced to teach it, Only 5% expressed interest, that they were only able to identify poetic rhythm by quantitative scanning. These experiences were provided to a number of literature teachers in District One of Sanandaj during a training course, the feedback of which was a complete success (retraining). I also asked an educational sciences colleague from the University to review all the steps as an outside observer.
 
Result: findings show that the traditional methods for prosodic, makes it boring and a bit difficult for the students. The subject (the faculty that we talk about) has invented a new method according to his own experiences about this kind of problems in his schooling period.
This method is taught collectively and simultaneously repeats by learners. Therefore, individual questions about meter recognition by hearing, especially at the beginning of the semester, should be strictly avoided.
The nature of this study is to describe the achievement of this teaching method and how to implement it. The most appropriate method was to use auto-ethnography. Therefore, by choosing this method, the researcher first recounted his teaching experiences using this method; then recounted the factors that motivated him to find a new way to teach the subject of prosodic, and finally represented his teaching experiences with the aim of sharing these experiences with colleagues and teachers of the subject.
This model was implemented in a class of 40 people for one semester and at the end of the semester students were tested orally and in writing. The results showed the complete success of this educational model in learning Prosodic. The results showed the complete success of this educational model in learning pronouns, so that 85% of the learners could recognize all contexts of agreed elements, alternating elements (distance) and the various elements well by hearing. 15 percent of learners recognized 90 percent of the meter, but sometimes had little difficulty recognizing various elements meter. The result also showed the ability to recognize the appropriateness or disproportion of the meter of the poems with their content in learners. The researcher implemented this project with long intervals both in the pre-university and undergraduate levels of Persian literature, both of which were successful; With the difference that the learning process in pre-university learners was faster than university students due to lack of mental background But in literature students having a negative mental background, due to traditional education because of passing this course in high school, along with mental fragmentation when asking to repeat the meter of the poem aloud, in the first two or three sessions, in the learning process creates noise. This problem was solved by teaching the release of the mind and reminding not to fragment the meter in the mind, and this issue increased their self-confidence and made them more credible in this teaching method. Priority of teaching the meter of agreed elements, alternating elements (distance) and the various elements , respectively, using poems appropriate to the interest and age of the learners, avoiding hymns with verbal and spiritual conviction, asking students to participate in group activities based on Repeating meter groups , pounding slowly on the floor or pounding the hand on the table evenly with the rhythm of the poem, while creating a happy atmosphere for students, played a key role in making them more confident in succeeding in learning the prosodic.
 
In this method because we want to dominate the acceptance of irregular teaching, first it was necessary to notice some preconditions like phoneme, poetical invective, scansion, metrical spelling, metrical teeth, then rely on preparing a suitable lesson plan rely on macro-strategy (at university level and educational centers) and micro-strategy (at class level) we can answer their educational needs.
Preparing interesting examples of poems, using functional and soft metrics, educating mind triggering, presenting examples that has harmony with cultures and be adequate with the student’s age and emotional, and finally using participatory learning-teaching guidelines makes this lesson one of the interesting lessons for the students and they successfully could learn the rhythm and meter, educating mind triggering, presenting examples that has harmony.

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • irregular teaching
  • prosodic
  • rhythm
  • music
  • auto-ethnography
Abdollahzade, H. Abdollahzade, H., & Abdollahzade, H.(2016). Studying and criticizing the quantity of consonants, vowels and syllables in Persian prosody and giving some suggestions. Journal of B00stan Adab. Shiraz University, V8,PP.171-190[in Persian].
Al-Razi, Sh. (1994). Al- mojam fi Maayir-e Ashaar-e Elajam. By Shamissa,S. Tehran: Ferdous [in Persian].
Bazargan, A. (2015). Introduction to Qualitative and  interdisciplinary Research Methods(Common Appoaches to Behavioral Sciences) Tehran: Print visit.
Dex, S. (1991). Life and  work history analysis: qualitative and  qualitative developments, London and  New York.
Farzad, M. (1950). "Metre Set of Persian Poetry”. Journal of Kherad-VAKooshesh. No.8, P. 584- 651.
Fazeli, N. (2017). Auto-ethnography the Academic Identity: How Iranain Human Identity as aResearcher or an Academic Human is formed? Tehran:Tisa Publication.
Fouladi,M., &  Zand, A.(2015) Studying external and lateral music in odes and sonnets of Zahir Fryabi. Literary Art. Vol.2(15), PP165-178[in Persian].
Ghanbari, M., & Almasi, L.(2017). Description of Become a Teacher: Auto Ethnography of a Fargangian University Gradute. Journal of Research in Teaching, Vol 5, No 4,PP. 71-97[in Persian].
Golzari, Z., & Attaran, M. (2016). Flipped Learning in Higher Education: Narratives of a Teacher, Journal of Theory and  Practice in Curriculum, Vol.7(4), 81-136[in Persian].
Khaghani Sharvani,  A.  (1996).  Divan-e  Khaghani.Tehran: Markaz.
Lichtman,  M.  (2011)  Reading  Case  Studies  in  M  Lichtman(E.d),  Understanding  and   Evaluating  Qualitative  Educational,  Research(pp.-108-138).  Thound  Oas  Ks,  Ca Sage  pablications.
Natel Khanlary,  P.  (1966).  The  Rhythm  of Persian’s  Poetry.  Tehran: Tous  [in  Persian]. Najafi,  A.(1973).  Jong_e  Isfahan  (Isfahan  Collection).V.10.  [in  Persian].
Najafi,  A.(2015).  About  the  classification  of  Persian  poetry  rhythms,  Twhran:  Nilufar,  . [in  Persian].
Naqhavi,  A.,  &  Mohammadi,  E.  (2014).  Auto-ethnography:  A  New  Research  Method  in Health  and  Rehabilitation  Studies  (The  first  Part)  J  Res  Rehabil  Sci  2014;  11(6): 418-424.
Mohseni,M.,  &  Sarahati  Juybari,  M.(2017).  Prominent  stylistic  aspects  in  music  of  Nāser Khosrow's  poetry.  Literary  Art.  Vol.1(18),  PP91-108[in  Persian].
Ma’dankankan,  M.,  Vahed,A.,  &    Abdollahzade,  H.(2017).  Reviewing  the  musical component  of  rhythm  of  "poetry"  and  the  factors  influencing  it.  Literary  Art. Vol.9(18),  PP39-52[in  Persian].
Parsa,  A.  (2011).  The  Effectiveness  of  The  Inductive  and    Deductive  Methods  In  Teaching Persian  Grammar  To  L.1  High  School Students  from  Shiraz,  Persian  Language  and   Literature  Quarterly  Journal,  Journal  of  Islamic  Azad  university,  N.6,PP.61-80[in Persian].
Pitard,  J.  (2019).  Auto-ethnography  as  a  Phenomenological  Tool:  Connecting  the Personal  to  the  Cultural.  In:  Liamputtong  P.  (eds)  Handbook  of  Research  Methods in  Health  Social  Sciences.  Singapore:  Springer.
Rosenthal,  G.,  &  Fisher-  Rosenthal,  W.(2004)  The  analysis  of  narrative  biographical interviews,  U.  Flick,  etal (eds)  A.  Companion  to  qualitative  research,  London:  Sage .
Rumi,  J.  (2002).  The  Mathnawi,  Edited  and  Translated  by  Nicholson,  R.  A.  Tehran: Soad Pablisher(Book  1).
Saabani,  V.B.  (2007).Transcendental  Realism  and  False  dichotomy  educational  research. Educational  Innovations,  20(22).  [in  Persian].
Shahhosani,  N.  )1988(.  Poetry  Identification  (Prosody).  Tehran: Homa  [in  Persian].
Sutton,  E.  (1976).  The  Persian  Meters.  Kingdom:  Cambridge.
Shamissa,  S.  (2001).  An  Introduction  Prosody,  Tehran: Ferdous  [in  Persian].
Solaymani,  E.,  &    Ahmadi,  H.  (2017)  Identifying  Obstacles  to  Implementing  Lesson- Study:  A  Case  Study  of  Primary  Schools  of  Education  in  Ardebil(A  mixed  Method), Journal  of  Research  in  Teaching,  5(1).  65-85[in  Persian].
Tabibzade,O.(2015).  Critique  and  review  of  Abolhassan  Najafi's  prosody  theory, Farhangestan,  Nama-ye  Farhangestan,  [in  Persian].
Wahidiyan  Kamyar,  T. (1995).  The  rhythm  and  rhyme  of  Persian  poetry.Tehran:  Samt.  [in Persian].
Yazdanpour,n.,  Yousofi,  A.,  &    Haqani,F.(2014).  The  effect  of  project-oriented  and cooperation  based  education  on  the  educational  dewelopment of third  grade  female experimental  science  students  in  Folad  Shahr  in  the  course  Statistics  and  Model Marking,  Knowledge  and  Research  in  Educational  and  Planning,  22:  85-89[in Persian].
Zare  Sefat,  S.,Dehghani,  M.,  &  Javadipour,  M.(2017).  Analysis  of mental containersof first  secendry  dchool students  in  teaching  Symphony.  Journal  of  Research  in Teaching,  5(2),  17-33[in  Persian].